ScholarMate
English简体中文繁體中文
客服热线:400-1616-289
登录注册
期刊论文

Low methodological quality of systematic reviews on acupuncture: a cross-sectional study

Ho, Leonard; Ke, Fiona Y. T.; Wong, Charlene H. L.; Wu, Irene X. Y.*; Cheung, Andy K. L.; Mao, Chen; Chung, Vincent C. H.南方医科大学; 5
BMC Medical Research Methodology2021-10-30DOI: 10.1186/s12874-021-01437-0
9被引11阅读
引用收藏
分享

摘要

Background While well-conducted systematic reviews (SRs) can provide the best evidence on the potential effectiveness of acupuncture, limitations on the methodological rigour of SRs may impact the trustworthiness of their conclusions. This cross-sectional study aimed to evaluate the methodological quality of a representative sample of SRs on acupuncture effectiveness. Methods Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, MEDLINE, and EMBASE were searched for SRs focusing on the treatment effect of manual acupuncture or electro-acupuncture published during January 2018 and March 2020. Eligible SRs must contain at least one meta-analysis and be published in English language. Two independent reviewers extracted the bibliographical characteristics of the included SRs with a pre-designed questionnaire and appraised the methodological quality of the studies with the validated AMSTAR 2 (A MeaSurement Tool to Assess systematic Reviews 2). The associations between bibliographical characteristics and methodological quality ratings were explored using Kruskal-Wallis rank tests and Spearman's rank correlation coefficients. Results A total of 106 SRs were appraised. Only one (0.9%) SR was of high overall methodological quality, zero (0%) was of moderate-quality, six (5.7%) and 99 (93.4%) were of low-quality and critically low-quality respectively. Among appraised SRs, only ten (9.4%) provided an a priori protocol, four (3.8%) conducted a comprehensive literature search, five (4.7%) provided a list of excluded studies, and six (5.7%) performed meta-analysis appropriately. Cochrane SRs, updated SRs, and SRs that did not search non-English databases had relatively higher overall quality. Conclusions Methodological quality of SRs on acupuncture is unsatisfactory. Future reviewers should improve critical methodological aspects of publishing protocols, performing comprehensive search, providing a list of excluded studies with justifications for exclusion, and conducting appropriate meta-analyses. These recommendations can be implemented via enhancing the technical competency of reviewers in SR methodology through established education approaches as well as quality gatekeeping by journal editors and reviewers. Finally, for evidence users, skills in SR critical appraisal remain to be essential as relevant evidence may not be available in pre-appraised formats.

学科与关键词

关键词
Evidence-based practiceMeta-analysisAcupunctureResearch designSystematic reviews
相关
加载中…
  • Evidence mapping and overview of systematic reviews of the effects of acupuncture therapies
    Lu, Liming; Zhang, Yuqing; Ge, Shuqi; Wen, Hao; Tang, Xiaorong; Zeng, Jing Chun; Wang, Lai; Zeng, Zhao; Rada, Gabriel; Avila, Camila; Vergara, Camilo; Chen, Rouhao; Dong, Yu; Wei, Xiaojing; Luo, Wen; Wang, Lin; Guyatt, Gordon; Tang, Chun-Zhi; Xu, Neng-Gui*BMJ Open, 2022, 12(6): e056803.被引 8
  • Research methods and efficacy of acupuncture in the treatment of Parkinson's disease: a scoping review of systematic reviews and meta-analyses
    Yu, Bin; Ma, Shi-qi; Huang, Hai-peng*; Zhong, Zhen; Yu, Shuo; Huang, Ke; Zhang, Li-ying; Li, Meng-yuan; Yao, LinFrontiers in Neurology, 2023, 14: 1196446.
  • Methodological quality of systematic reviews on treatments for Alzheimer's disease: a cross-sectional study
    Zhong, Claire C. W.; Zhao, Jinglun; Wong, Charlene H. L.; Wu, Irene X. Y.*; Mao, Chen; Yeung, Jerry W. F.; Chung, Vincent C. H.Alzheimers Research & Therapy, 2022, 14(1): 159.被引 4
查看全部 →

发表信息

论文状态
公开发表
期刊
BMC Medical Research Methodology
发表日期
2021-10-30
卷期
第 21 卷, 第 1 期
页码
237
DOI
10.1186/s12874-021-01437-0
语言
ENGLISH
期刊收录
NSL
期刊等级
3区
成果收录
SCIE
资助标注
National Natural Science Foundation of China [81973709]; Hunan Nature Science Foundation [2019JJ40348]

作者

  • H

    Ho, Leonard (第一作者)

    chinese univ hong kong

  • K

    Ke, Fiona Y. T.

    chinese univ hong kong

查看全部 7 位作者收起作者
  • W

    Wong, Charlene H. L.

    chinese univ hong kong

  • W

    Wu, Irene X. Y. (通讯)

    5

  • C

    Cheung, Andy K. L.

    chinese univ hong kong

  • M

    Mao, Chen

    southern med univ

  • C

    Chung, Vincent C. H.

    chinese univ hong kong

登录解锁更多功能

  • 收藏这篇,随时在“我的 · 收藏”找回
  • 认领你的成果,生成推广素材
  • 关注作者获取最新成果
  • 加入项目组、协同写作
注册 / 登录

产品服务

  • 科研之友
  • 创新城
  • 科创云

服务支持

  • 帮助中心
  • 隐私政策
  • 服务条款

联系方式

在线客服:【】
客服热线:400-1616-289
电子邮箱:support@scholarmate.com

关注或下载科研之友

微信二维码
微信公众号
客户端下载二维码
下载客户端
科研成果科研人员科研机构科研动态爱瑞思软件

©2026 深圳市科研之友网络服务有限公司

公安备案图标粤公网安备 44030502000213
粤ICP备 16046710 号粤B2-20110417