摘要
Background: There has been a substantial increase in the development of artificial intelligence (AI) tools for clinical decisionsupport. Historically, these were mostly knowledge-based systems, but recent advances include non-knowledge-based systemsusing some form of machine learning. The ability of health care professionals to trust technology and understand how it benefitspatients or improves care delivery is known to be important for their adoption of that technology. For non-knowledge-based AItools for clinical decision support, these issues are poorly understood.Objective: The aim of this study is to qualitatively synthesize evidence on the experiences of health care professionals inroutinely using non-knowledge-based AI tools to support their clinical decision-making.Methods: In June 2023, we searched 4 electronic databases, MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, and Web of Science, with nolanguage or date limit. We also contacted relevant experts and searched reference lists of the included studies. We included studiesof any design that reported the experiences of health care professionals using non-knowledge-based systems for clinical decisionsupport in their work settings. We completed double independent quality assessment for all included studies using the MixedMethods Appraisal Tool. We used a theoretically informed thematic approach to synthesize the findings.Results: After screening 7552 titles and 182 full-text articles, we included 25 studies conducted in 9 different countries. Mostof the included studies were qualitative (n=13), and the remaining were quantitative (n=9) and mixed methods (n=3). Overall,we identified 7 themes: health care professionals'understanding of AI applications, level of trust and confidence in AI tools,judging the value added by AI, data availability and limitations of AI, time and competing priorities, concern about governance,and collaboration to facilitate the implementation and use of AI. The most frequently occurring are the first 3 themes. For example,many studies reported that health care professionals were concerned about not understanding the AI outputs or the rationalebehind them. There were issues with confidence in the accuracy of the AI applications and their recommendations. Some healthcare professionals believed that AI provided added value and improved decision-making, and some reported that it only servedas a confirmation of their clinical judgment, while others did not find it useful at all.Conclusions: Our review identified several important issues documented in various studies on health care professionals'useof AI tools in real-world health care settings. Opinions of health care professionals regarding the added value of AI tools forsupporting clinical decision-making varied widely, and many professionals had concerns about their understanding of and trustin this technology. The findings of this review emphasize the need for concerted efforts to optimize the integration of AI toolsin real-world health care settings Trial Registration: PROSPERO CRD42022336359; https://tinyurl.com/2yunvkmb
学科与关键词
- Trust and acceptability of data-driven clinical recommendations in everyday practice: A scoping reviewEvans, Ruth P.*; Bryant, Louise D.; Russell, Gregor; Absolom, KateInternational Journal of Medical Informatics, 2024, 183: 105342.被引 5
- Patients' Perceptions Toward Human-Ar tificial Intelligence Interaction in Health Care: Experimental StudyEsmaeilzadeh, Pouyan*; Mirzaei, Tala; Dharanikota, SpurthyJOURNAL OF MEDICAL INTERNET RESEARCH, 2021, 23(11): e25856.被引 63
- AI-driven decision support systems and epistemic reliance: a qualitative study on obstetricians' and midwives' perspectives on integrating AI-driven CTG into clinical decision makingDlugatch, Rachel; Georgieva, Antoniya; Kerasidou, Angeliki*BMC Medical Ethics, 2024, 25(1): 6.被引 2
