ScholarMate
English简体中文繁體中文
客服热线:400-1616-289
登录注册
期刊论文

Kaplan-Meier Survival Analysis Overestimates the Risk of Revision Arthroplasty: A Meta-analysis

Lacny, Sarah; Wilson, Todd; Clement, Fiona; Roberts, Derek J.; Faris, Peter D.; Ghali, William A.; Marshall, Deborah A.*
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research2015-11DOI: 10.1007/s11999-015-4235-8
85被引1阅读
引用收藏
分享

摘要

Although Kaplan-Meier survival analysis is commonly used to estimate the cumulative incidence of revision after joint arthroplasty, it theoretically overestimates the risk of revision in the presence of competing risks (such as death). Because the magnitude of overestimation is not well documented, the potential associated impact on clinical and policy decision-making remains unknown. We performed a meta-analysis to answer the following questions: (1) To what extent does the Kaplan-Meier method overestimate the cumulative incidence of revision after joint replacement compared with alternative competing-risks methods? (2) Is the extent of overestimation influenced by followup time or rate of competing risks? We searched Ovid MEDLINE, EMBASE, BIOSIS Previews, and Web of Science (1946, 1980, 1980, and 1899, respectively, to October 26, 2013) and included article bibliographies for studies comparing estimated cumulative incidence of revision after hip or knee arthroplasty obtained using both Kaplan-Meier and competing-risks methods. We excluded conference abstracts, unpublished studies, or studies using simulated data sets. Two reviewers independently extracted data and evaluated the quality of reporting of the included studies. Among 1160 abstracts identified, six studies were included in our meta-analysis. The principal reason for the steep attrition (1160 to six) was that the initial search was for studies in any clinical area that compared the cumulative incidence estimated using the Kaplan-Meier versus competing-risks methods for any event (not just the cumulative incidence of hip or knee revision); we did this to minimize the likelihood of missing any relevant studies. We calculated risk ratios (RRs) comparing the cumulative incidence estimated using the Kaplan-Meier method with the competing-risks method for each study and used DerSimonian and Laird random effects models to pool these RRs. Heterogeneity was explored using stratified meta-analyses and metaregression. The pooled cumulative incidence of revision after hip or knee arthroplasty obtained using the Kaplan-Meier method was 1.55 times higher (95% confidence interval, 1.43-1.68; p < 0.001) than that obtained using the competing-risks method. Longer followup times and higher proportions of competing risks were not associated with increases in the amount of overestimation of revision risk by the Kaplan-Meier method (all p > 0.10). This may be due to the small number of studies that met the inclusion criteria and conservative variance approximation. The Kaplan-Meier method overestimates risk of revision after hip or knee arthroplasty in populations where competing risks (such as death) might preclude the occurrence of the event of interest (revision). Competing-risks methods should be used to more accurately estimate the cumulative incidence of revision when the goal is to plan healthcare services and resource allocation for revisions.

学科与关键词

关键词
TOTAL HIP-ARTHROPLASTYCOMPETING RISKSSTATISTICAL-ANALYSISJOINT REPLACEMENTKNEE ARTHROPLASTYREGISTRIESTIMEPROBABILITYEVENTS
相关
加载中…

文献加载失败,请重试

重试

发表信息

论文状态
公开发表
期刊
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research
发表日期
2015-11
卷期
第 473 卷, 第 11 期
页码
3431-3442
DOI
10.1007/s11999-015-4235-8
语言
ENGLISH
期刊收录
SCIE
期刊等级
Q1
成果收录
SCIE

作者

  • L

    Lacny, Sarah (第一作者)

  • W

    Wilson, Todd

查看全部 7 位作者收起作者
  • C

    Clement, Fiona

  • R

    Roberts, Derek J.

  • F

    Faris, Peter D.

  • G

    Ghali, William A.

  • M

    Marshall, Deborah A. (通讯)

登录解锁更多功能

  • 收藏这篇,随时在“我的 · 收藏”找回
  • 认领你的成果,生成推广素材
  • 关注作者获取最新成果
  • 加入项目组、协同写作
注册 / 登录

产品服务

  • 科研之友
  • 创新城
  • 科创云

服务支持

  • 帮助中心
  • 隐私政策
  • 服务条款

联系方式

在线客服:【】
客服热线:400-1616-289
电子邮箱:support@scholarmate.com

关注或下载科研之友

微信二维码
微信公众号
客户端下载二维码
下载客户端
科研成果科研人员科研机构科研动态爱瑞思软件

©2026 深圳市科研之友网络服务有限公司

公安备案图标粤公网安备 44030502000213
粤ICP备 16046710 号粤B2-20110417